October 18, 2026
avatar-torie-bosch
First Opinion Editor

This week came with three wonderful things — and a terrible one.

First, we had the STAT Summit in Boston, where I had the pleasure of seeing past and future First Opinion contributors. It’s a rare joy to get to discuss potential op-eds with people in person. Thanks to everyone who took a moment to chat with me.

Second, a bit of a dream came true: First Opinion launched “Friendly Argument,” a new occasional feature in which two people who like each other but disagree debate an idea in health and medicine. We launched with a discussion between John E. McDonough, author of the new book “America’s Wrong Turn: U.S. Healthcare in the Neoliberal Era,” and Stuart Butler, a scholar in residence in economic studies at the Brookings Institution. They debated Milton Friedman, where U.S. health care went wrong, and how to get it back on track. Who do you want to take part in the next Friendly Argument about medicine and health policy? Share your ideas, or volunteer yourself and someone you’d like to debate, by emailing first.opinion@statnews.com.

Third, we launched the latest STAT+ First Opinion column: Chief Complaint, by Frances Mei Hardin, author of the wonderful memoir “Surgeon on the Edge.” Frances Mei, a former ENT surgeon, will write about the challenges facing physicians working in a health care system undergoing enormous change. In her first column, she examines the epidemic of learned helplessness among doctors.

Most importantly: I can’t let this newsletter end without remembering my wonderful colleague Helen Branswell, who died this week from complications related to cancer. When I first started at STAT, I was intimidated by Helen, the queen of Covid coverage. But I quickly got to know her astonishing generosity of spirit and intellect. When I asked her to review a First Opinion submission in her wheelhouse, she was always blunt — and always right. Be sure to read Helen’s STAT obituary, written by her close collaborator Andrew Joseph.

Recommendation of the week: I’m celebrating October and spooky season by re-reading “The Little Stranger,” by Sarah Waters, a Gothic novel set in postwar England about a crumbling grand house haunted by upper-class anxiety and maybe also ghosts.



Courtesy Gabriel Hongsdusit/CalMatters

MyChart said I could opt out of sharing my health data. Figuring out how was maddening

Investigation co-published with CalMatters/The Markup shows how confusing patient portals and conflicting rules hamper opt-outs of widely used EHR systems.

By Alex Rosenblat — CalMatters/The Markup


My daughter’s death changed how I understood the nursing shortage

Nurses' working conditions are the larger problem

By Lynne S. Moronski


I thought I knew why patients stopped taking their medicine. I was wrong

Understanding that their medication is necessary isn’t always enough

By Marcela Gottschald


Milton Friedman.
STAFF/AFP via Getty Images

Is Milton Friedman to blame for America’s health care woes?

John E. McDonough and Stuart Butler debate McDonough's book "America’s Wrong Turn: U.S. Healthcare in the Neoliberal Era."

By Stuart Butler and John E. McDonough


We think a baby’s gut microbiome could be key to lifelong brain health

Growing evidence suggests the developing brain takes instructions from somewhere perhaps unexpected: the gut microbiome.

By Holly Baines and George Vradenburg


How states can resist the potential Trump vaccine shortages

Policymakers at the state level can step in to directly produce vaccines to prevent shortages and harm to the American people.

By Joel Dodge


California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation via Getty Images

Lethal injection will never be the same after Christa Pike’s botched execution

Pre-Christa Pike, lethal injection was “passing” as a “death with dignity” medical assistance in dying procedure. No more.

By M. Sara Rosenthal


STAT+ | The epidemic of learned helplessness in physicians

Medical training teaches doctors deference. Increasingly, that deference seems to follow them through their careers.

By Frances Mei Hardin


More around STAT

Play

Play: What's the word? Test your knowledge with today's mini crossword

 
 
STAT
STAT, 1 Exchange Place, Boston, MA
©2026, All Rights Reserved.